Oct 7, 2017 Employment Explosion
June 26, 2017 Why's the FED Panicking?
May 25, 2017 LFPR anyone?
Apr 26, 2017 What's up with the FED?
March 10, 2017 Feb Employment Situation
Oct 10, 2016 Tax Burden
Aug 1, 2016 Here Comes the Debt
June 26, 2016 Moribund US Economy
June 16 2016 Labor Update
Mar 10, 2016 Spring Renewal for Labor Markets?
Feb 21, 2016 GDP Gap
Feb 16, 2016 FED and Monetary Policy
Jan 19, 2016 Employment Gap Age Groups LFPR
Jan 10, 2016 A look at the Employment Situation
Dec 30, 2015 Fed Funds Rate up 25 Basis points...so what?
Dec 15, 2015 Fed Funds on the rise? Has Yellen 'Fell-in'?
Oct 15, 2015 Labor Markets Seven years of misery
Oct 6, 2015 Sept: Horrible Month for Labor
Sept 30, 2015 The FED: Interest Rate Angst
Sept 11, 2015 FED on the Monetary Policy Front
July 31, 2015 Trade and Foreign Exchange Rates
July 20, 2015 Economic Growth?
July 10, 2015 Labor Picture by Age Group
July 2, 2015 Disastrous Month in Labor Rpt
June 19, 2015 Minimum Wage - Income Distribution
Jun 5, 2015 Encouraged Worker Effect
May 8, 2015 Updated Employment Situation for April
May 4, 2015 Languishing Labor Markets
Apr 7, 2015 LFPR Doldrums on the Labor Front
March 8, 2015 Less than Zero Interest Rates - Trade War
2014 Articles
2013 Articles
2012 Articles
2011 & 2010 Articles
Dec 23, 2011 Revisionist History Depression
Dec 10, 2011 Depression & Now Part 1
Dec 5, 2011 Lies, Damned Lies, Statistics
Nov 16, 2011 Taxes Part 2
Nov 8, 2011 Taxes Pt 1
Nov 1, 2011 Demographics
Oct 12, 2011 Fed-FOMC
Oct 6, 2011 Fed's Operation Twist
Sep 30, 2011 What Price Bailouts?!
Sep 9, 2011 Trade Deficit - States
Sept 3, 2011 Unemployment Ongoing Challenge
August 22, 2011 Restricting Oil Supply
August 11, 2011 Credit Rating-Taxes
August 8, 2011 QE3? What to do?
Aug 5, 2011 Employment Update
August 1, 2011 Competitive Free Mkt Capitalism
July 26, 2011 Cradle of Democracy
July 16, 2011 Capital Ratios
July 10, 2011 Unemployment Again
July 1, 2011 QE2 Over-Apres Moi, le Deluge
June 11, 2011 Unemployment
June 8, 2011 Net Worth Collapse
May 18 2011 Credit Collapse '08-'10
May 15, 2011 Fed Miracle-Mayhem
May 10, 2011 Unemployment
Mar 30, 2011 Puppet Show
Mar 18, 2011 Locked-in-Effect
Mar 10, 2011 Bummer Days
Feb 12 2011 Inflation by Decontenting
Feb 6 2011 Unemployment
Jan 14 2011 Money Supply
Jan 12 2011 Trade Deficit
Jan 6 2011 Printing Press Myth
Dec 18, 2010 College Pricing
Dec 7 2010 Debt & Deficits
Dec 2, 2010 J-Laffer Curve
Sep 24 2010 Competition
Sept 23 2010 Trade Deficit China
About us
Links of Interest
Straw Poll
Definitions & Miscellaneous

Economic Newsletter for the New Millennium

November 1, 2011

Donald R. Byrne, Ph.D.

Associate Editor
Edward T. Derbin, MA, MBA

Download Current Blog 

US Demographics: Increasing costs; aging population


The editor of this newsletter just finished writing a letter of support to the City of Livonia’s Planning Commission concerning the private sector construction of senior citizen housing.  I pointed out that the long heralded entry of Baby Boomers into retirement has finally begun in earnest. 





"…baby-boomers (born 1946 - 1964) are beginning to retire; some at age 65, but many of them at much younger ages.  The inherent problem with people retiring, even at 65, is that many of those people will live for another 20-25 years.  The increased longevity is a wonderful thing (we're all for it!!!), but it has to be supported.  There's no reason why people shouldn't continue to work well into their 'golden years'.  It's all a matter of matching people with the suitable job."

A pre-shock has already occurred with the inception of the current economic malaise, The Great Recession.  Among the miserable data streaming out at us are two series, early retirements and permanent disability claims.  They have literally gone through the roof.  We might call them the extremely discouraged workers with no hope of ever finding a job.  I have had lunch with a few of them lately!  They are for real and they in general are very well educated and in the past have held very responsible jobs.


The U.S. economy has been experiencing significant increases in early retirements and claimants being granting permanent disability status.  We here at the New Economic Paradigm Associates have coined the term “Very Discouraged Workers.”  These two groups also reduce the labor force participation rate and obscure the seriousness of the unemployment problem.



All Social Security disabled beneficiaries in current-payment status, December 1970–2009

“The number of disabled workers grew steadily until 1978, declined slightly until 1983, started to increase again in 1984, and began to increase more rapidly beginning in 1990.  The growth in the 1980s and 1990s was the result of demographic changes, a recession, and legislative changes.  The number of disabled adult children has grown slightly, and the number of disabled widow(er)s has remained fairly level.  In December 2009, about 7.8 million disabled workers, just under 921,000 disabled adult children, and over 236,000 disabled widow(er)s received disability benefits.”

“A stubborn and severe recession is exacerbating the dismal job outlook and causing accelerated early retirements from the labor force, seeking long term disability status, and an increasing reality of very long duration unemployment.” 



“Lack of jobs is now THE major problem in the U.S. economy.  A stubborn and severe recession is exacerbating the dismal job outlook and causing accelerated early retirements from the labor force, record numbers seeking long term disability status, and an increasing number of very long duration unemployed.  The U.S. is beginning to look a lot like Europe!”







Retirement and Disability on the Rise.jpg

Of immediate interest are the early retirement numbers.  The period from 1946 through 1964 was one of very high birth rates.  The first four years of that group have already reached 62 and are eligible to apply for early retirement and Social Security benefits and Medicare (age 64 and 8 months, earlier, if you are on Disability).  A relatively large number have already done so as the above graph clearly shows.  Now the full onslaught is beginning as those born in 1946 have reached the ripe old age of 65. 

LA Times – May 24, 2009 (Mike Dorning)


Instead of seeing older workers staying on the job longer as the economy has worsened, the Social Security system is reporting a major surge in early retirement claims that could have implications for the financial security of millions of baby boomers. 

Since the current federal fiscal year began Oct. 1, claims have been running 25% ahead of last year, compared with the 15% increase that had been projected as the post-World War II generation reaches eligibility for early retirement, according to Stephen C. Goss, chief actuary for the Social Security Administration.

It is happening at the worst of times, in the midst of the economic and financial malaise now being termed the Great Recession.  The pressure on government will rapidly mount to provide for the senior citizens, an age group that is less able to cope for themselves.  If the pattern of increasing government involvement for the low income members of our population is indicative of what will happen in the area of government intervention into senior citizen welfare concerns (such as Medicare), a flood of programs will begin to flow from the federal and state legislatures that will swamp an already over-burdened municipal governments. The stupidity of such programs as 30 years of work and out combined with increasing longevity will become very clear. 

When the experience of these events and the resulting challenges do become clear, consumer spending may take a serious hit as the public begins to realize that retirement’s ‘golden years’, are ONLY gold if the retirees have accumulated enough wealth to see them through and they can afford reasonable health care.

Retirements and Disability on the Rise.jpg

Medicare Beneficiaries.jpg



Medicare Beneficiaries v Workers.jpg



Department of Health and Human Services – (CMS) Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services 

FYI - Nearly a third of the U.S. population is receiving some degree of government financed healthcare…

“I am pleased to present the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services’ (CMS) fiscal year (FY) 2011 performance budget. Our programs will touch the lives of almost 102 million Medicare, Medicaid, and Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP) beneficiaries in FY 2011.”

Charlene Frizzera - Acting Administrator (CMS) Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services

“The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) oversees three of the nation’s largest health care programs: Medicare, Medicaid, and the Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP). CMS is the largest purchaser of health care in the United States and expects to serve almost 102 million beneficiaries in FY 2011. In FY 2009, CMS spent $782 billion on benefits and other costs.”

“For more than 40 years, Medicare and Medicaid have helped pay the medical bills of millions of older and low-income Americans, providing them with reliable health benefits. We expect to serve almost 102 million beneficiaries in FY 2011, roughly one in three Americans. Medicare and Medicaid combined pay about one-third of the Nation’s health expenditures.”


Established in 1965, the Medicare program provides hospital and supplemental medical insurance to Americans age 65 and older and to disabled persons, including those with end-stage renal disease. The program was expanded in 2003 to include a voluntary prescription drug benefit.  Medicare enrollment has increased from 19 million in 1966 to over 48 million beneficiaries in 2011.


Data Source: *CMS Office of the Actuary estimate. 17 States have reported a total of 15,805,766 beneficiaries enrolled. CMS will continue to work with States in order to obtain full reports from every State.

Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP)

In 2008, eleven years after CHIP was created, States reported that 7.4 million children were enrolled in the program. The Children’s Health Insurance Program Reauthorization Act of 2009 (P.L. 111-3) reauthorized CHIP from April 2009 through September 30, 2013 and increased funding by $44 billion through 2013 to maintain State programs and to cover more insured children. In response to the funding increase, CMS revised a performance measure to decrease the number of uninsured children by working with States to enroll children in CHIP. CMS exceeded its FY 2008 target to increase CHIP enrollment by 2 percent over the FY 2006 baseline enrollment figure. The FY 2006 baseline was 6,600,000 and our FY 2008 result was 7,368,479, an increase of over 11 percent.

POLITICIANS BEWARE!  Absentee ballots are beginning to change the outcomes of elections.  Senior citizens voting in elections show a much larger percentage than do other groups.

SENIOR CITIZENS BEWARE!  You may have heard of what appears to be a growing tendency for election fraud in regard to the counting of absentee ballots.  It is equally critical as to when the absentee ballots are counted are reported as the running counts of partial election results can influence the desire of those voting later on election day to actually vote and for whom to vote.  Counting absentee ballots as an AFERTHOUGHT may effectively influence the election outcomes against the preferences of the senior citizens.

It should be also noted that many demographers speak of a DEMOGRAPHIC WINTER (http://www.demographicwinter.com/index.html).  The baby boomers (born from 1946-64) were followed by what I prefer to call a BIRTH DEARTH.  This occurred from 1965 to about 1983 with the age of ZPG or zero population growth advocates.  It is a problem not only here in the U.S. of A. but in places like Western Europe at the present time.  Just below are current reproduction rates, some of which of imploding populations and a rise in immigration rates to fill the void.  This often leads to culture shocks as immigrants do not share the same cultural values of the populations of the countries into which the immigrants are migrating.


Collapsing Population.jpg

Shrinking Japan.jpg

Germany Shrinking.jpg

An everchanging US 2050.jpg

Population Cohorts moving forward.jpg

Population Pyramid US 2050.jpg

March 2011 - Population Reference Bureau

US Population Pyramid 2010-30-50.jpg

“Between 2010 and 2050, the U.S. popula­tion is projected to grow from 310 million to 439 million, an increase of 42 percent. The nation will also become more racially and ethnically diverse, with the aggregate minority population projected to become the majority in 2042.* The population is also expected to become much older, with nearly one in five U.S. residents aged 65 and older in 2030.”


The Older Population in the United States:
2010 to 2050
Population Estimates and Projections (Current Population Reports)
U.S. Department of Commerce
Economics and Statistics Administration
Issued May 2010

Aging US.jpg




Aging US 2.jpg

Rising Elderly Population.jpg

Recall the massive change in job outlook(s) back in the Post WWII days as the Baby Boom was occurring.  Doctors were switching from Gerontology to OB/GYN and then Pediatrics.  Schools of Education were exploding with growth as many saw the teaching field expand from vocation to profession.  The housing industry flourished, with baby-sitters became a necessity and so on.

Now we are seeing a major reversal as the population ages.  There is a serious problem however.  The current productive resources base (labor, debt and equity capital, entrepreneurship and land) must support the entire population.  If the retirees have saved and accumulated significant wealth in pensions, etc., there must be a transfer from those productive resources currently employed to those becoming retirees and not actively engaged in the production process – other than as capitalists supplying their retirement assets.  Even here, if the retirees desire to dis-accumulate their wealth to raise their material level of goods and services, it is up to the active resource base and the public, participating in the production process, to buy the assets and pay the taxes to support such programs as Social Security and Medicare.  Consider the burden of illegal immigrants into this country.  The pressure is great to give them the same rights and benefits as those who legally migrated.  States like Arizona and California are reeling under the fiscal burdens to do so.  You can argue until Hell freezes over about the moral merits and demerits of doing so.  The emerging picture is clear.  It points to the consequences of ‘doing so’ and the ever-increasing strain on the already near-bankrupt state and local governments.